Monday 30 October 2023

Montreal Street Underpass - Foundations Found

In a previous post on the Montreal Street underpass (also called the Montreal Street subway) I mentioned the difficulty I've had trying to reconcile what's left there today. I've read many reports of foundations of the steel CN Kingston Subdivision bridge that spanned Montreal Street extant at the site today. I snapped the above photo from the site of the former subway in 2021 and couldn't figure it out even while standing there! But with so much earthmoving, realignment of rails and roads, and 40+ years of intervening time since the bridge's removal in 1976, it's understandably a challenge. Until tonight.

Terry Ethridge was recently at the site and kindly shared his photos that led me to the answers.

Terry's phone map shows the three extant foundations he found, marked in black (above). The most obvious one of the original four is close to the Village on the River apartments on the Cataraqui River. The second largest is along Montreal Street. This view of Terry's is from the current alignment of Montreal Street, looking toward the apartment parking lot and river:
The largest extant foundation (squiggly yellow line at top right of above photo) is close to Village Drive.which leads to the apartments. Terry moved closer to it (below).
This excellent view by Terry faces the opposite direction showing the largest foundation, with remains of a recently removed tree:
What really cinched this for me was using the City of Kingston's Snapshot Kingston mapping tool. Able to apply different year layers, I chose the 1970 layer, then toggled a more recent one, 2013. I could easily match Terry's photos to the satellite/aerial views 43 years apart. If I was more tech-savvy, I would have made a video of one morphing to the other. Instead, here's an old-school side-by-side view. I framed the same area, showing the two most-prominent foundation locations with red arrows on the 2013 side. All four foundations framing the CN double-track mainline above Montreal Street shown on the 1970 side. I also marked the recently removed tree. To orient the view, I placed a yellow box around the limestone Grand Trunk Terrace (GTT) on Cassidy Street: 
An amazing metamorphosis over the intervening years. Interestingly, this large, brown utility building in the Village on the River parking lot was formerly the Chown warehouse, rail-served off CN's Hanley Spur which was just east of the mainline and closer to the river, track passing to the left:
Who would guess that on this quiet greenspace once rolled the mighty freight trains and fleeting Limiteds of the Grand Trunk and Canadian National eras in the past nearly-150 years!

Thanks to Terry Ethridge for his assistance with this post.

River St. Diamond Redux

A signature scene that defines Kingston's Hanley Spur is the diamond crossing of CP over CN at River Street. When I laid track on my layout, I only had a 30-degree diamond. This required quite a flareout and straightening of the CP track as it crossed CN. To be prototypical, the CP and CN tracks need to be just a few feet apart, but my resulting distance was too large. But that's all I had to work with.

At the Associated Railroaders of Kingston Rail Fair train show in October, I picked up a handful of diamonds. I should clarify....these were all Atlas snap-track diamond crossings of track at various angles, from 90 degrees down to 19 degrees purchased from Sam MacLauchlan. And each was bargain-priced at $2. 

So, I decided to re-do the diamond crossing situated right under the River Street bridge. One downside of this is that my current CP alignment near the backdrop meant I could serve the Woolen Mill, Dyeco and C E MacPherson with switches leading to spurs right off the 'main' track 'north' of the diamond.

As part of this re-do, I decided to add another track (Oops, I did it again!) to serve those three industries. While that meant adding a switch, it actually removed three switches from the 'main' track. Before construction started - the new diamond is at centre, CN at left and CP at right near backdrop:
I started by removing the bridge, removing the diamond, adding the new diamond and see where that left my trackplan! Although the 19-degree diamond gave me a nice, close CP-to-CN distance, it threw off the approaches to the CP customers on the 'south' side of the diamond. (Although I would love to have an anatomically-correct arrangement of spurs off the CP, the constrained space available on my 10x11-foot layout just didn't allow for this nicety.)
Progress photos. 
Above - the old 30-degree diamond (D)and two switches (S) off CP 'main' track
Below - the new 19-degree diamond and two relocated switches  
Note the distance between the decreased distance between CP and CN (lower arrow):
All track back in place. The boxcar is on the CP, with Dyeco to left, switchback to Woolen Mill and C E MacPherson off to the right.
As a result, I flared the Sowards coal spur and Anglin/Canadian Dredge & Dock/Anglin spur out from the diamond, resulting in a more gentle curve to the spurs from the rather severe 19-degree diamond. The finished diamond scene (below hey CN boxcar go home, you're lost! and view from other side of bridge in top photo).
I did something I really shouldn't have. I added a switchback (S in photo below), the 'north' end of which serves two spurs prototypically some distance separate from each other. Aaagh! I hope to revisit and revise this in the future, but for now it was expedient and allowed the Woolen Mill (WM), Dyeco and C E MacPherson (MAC) to all remain rail-served in my limited available space (photo below, with CP yellow lines and CN red lines)
I then took the opportunity to paint some of the ballast, rail, and ties when the track was lifted, making the black-tie and brass-track affair less obvious. Replacing the rail, I was pleased with the finished product, and the proximity of the CN and CP 'main' tracks under and past the River Street bridge on both sides! Final detailing awaits, including rebuilding the road crossing and replacing some poles and signs now that there is less space available due to the extra track. 

Saturday 28 October 2023

F.B. Hamer's Photos at CN's Outer Station, 1951

In this post, I'm honoured to be able to share photos and original captions of a nice selection of photos taken from various viewpoints around the sharp curve at Kingston's Outer Station in 1951 - taken by the late Frederick Brian Hamer and kindly shared by his son, Ottawa rail enthusiast and model railroader Mike Hamer.  I have had the pleasure of meeting Mike twice while I was a presenter to the Ottawa Valley Associated Railroaders. Mike noted that these images dating from the steam days were very small, but he copied and photographed them, along with the captions his father wrote for each image. Mike also said that it would be an honour to have his Dad's photos shared more widely, and that his Dad would love to know that others were able to enjoy them.  Sadly, Mike's Dad passed away a number of years ago but had lived well up into his early nineties - a long and treasured life. 

Mike introduces the photos, "Shortly after World War II ended, my parents found themselves living in Kingston, Ontario.  In the evening hours, following an early dinner they would hold a “date” a couple of nights each week.  With little money to spend, they would drive out to Kingston’s Outer Station to watch the parade of trains, and, if the local ball team were playing a night game, they’d head over to the ballpark afterwards to catch some of the action on the diamond. Before my Dad passed away, he compiled some of the old black and white images he snapped during these wonderful hours spent with Mom trackside.  He wrote me a note detailing the activities found in the images.  While these are grainy reproductions from very small images long lost, they offer up some tidbits of information of what the train scene was like at the time at Kingston’s Outer Station."

(I have included the captions that Mr. Hamer wrote to Mike in their entirety, with my additional comments [in square brackets] and minimal cropping and and editing of the vintage images). Let's travel back over 70 years, to a time when the Montreal Street station was a busy place and a portal to our city

A westbound passenger train starts from Kingston station behind a 4-8-4 locomotive [CN 6200].  Notice the sharp, right-hand curve in the tracks for the station.   This curve was in the middle of a long, uphill grade from the Cataraque River to higher ground west of the city.  Friction of the wheel flanges against the curved track added to the difficulty in starting.  I remember one occasion when a train was out of control on that up-grade and as it entered the curve in the station the locomotive left the track, fell on its side and slid into the station building.  One member of its crew died in that accident [and it will be featured in an upcoming issue of the Canadian Railway Historical Association publication Canadian Rail,  the impetus for our online discussion of these very photos].
At Kingston there were facilities to replenish the water tanks of main-line locomotives at both ends of the station.  The nearest coal towers were at Brockville, 50 miles to the east and at Belleville, 50 miles to the west.  The local switcher and wayfreight locomotive was laboriously coaled by shoveling coal into a large box which was lifted by a crane and dumped into the tender.  If several boxes were required this could be a lengthy process which was interesting to watch – but plain hard work for the engine’s crew. [CN E-10-a 924 was built by Kingston's own CLC in 1910 for the Grand Trunk Western, and scrapped a mere four years after this photo was taken.]
At the east end of Kingston’s Outer Station there had been a level crossing where Montreal Street crossed the tracks.  After a fatal accident between an auto and a train this was replaced by an underpass which was in the middle of an S-bend in the road.  Because this was a blind curve from either side it still was dangerous because there was only just room for two cars to pass under the bridge.  The entire “bottleneck” was eliminated years later.  The railroad was diverted to the north and the Outer Station became an industrial subdivision.  The bridge was removed and Montreal Street was straightened.  A new Kingston Station was built in the west end of an expanded city.
The 6400 class of 4-8-4 locomotives were intended for passenger trains only.  These locomotives were given a “skyline casing” over the various appurtenances on top of the boiler and the rounded front.  This semi-streamlining was for appearance only as it did almost nothing to reduce the drag of the irregular shapes on the locomotive, which themselves were only a tiny portion of the total drag of an entire train.
Let’s examine diesel traction.  Diesel, or Compression-Ignition engines had been used for many years in high-speed, torpedo boats in the world`s navies.  Apart from an experimental mainline unit built by CN in 1927, diesel power did not appear on railroads until the makers of diesel engines realized that a huge market would exist on world railroads if diesel locomotives could replace steam.  A start was made with low-horsepower locomotives for yardswitching and eventually progressed over 40 years to high-horsepower units for mainline trains.  In North America, the diesel engine usually drives an electric generator supplying power to the electric motors `nose-hung` from the truck frames to the axles.  In Europe, some diesel locomotives have hydraulic transmissions. [CN 9003 and a classmate built in 1948  by General Motors' Electro-Motive Division lead a westbound train.]
Passenger trains 6 and 15 meet at Kingston.  This photograph was taken at the west end of Kingston`s Station.  The westbound locomotive has had its fire built up to make steam for the climb ahead while the approaching eastbound train is coasting to its station stop.  It will probably replenish its water tank while passengers disembark, and others board the train while mail and express is loaded into the head-end cars immediately behind the locomotive. [This photo is a favourite of mine - a youngster covers his  ears - protecting them from what would have been deafening noise from these two behemoths!]
Reverse running of a locomotive on a passenger train is very rare and this picture shows one of those rare occasions.  The direction of the plume of smoke confirms the reverse running.  I believe this was an advance, extra section of a westbound train which did not stop at the Kingston station and so kept some ten minutes and eight or so miles ahead of the main train which followed.
Locomotive 5554 has a white flag mounted on its handrail, close to the front of the boiler.  There will be a similar flag on the other side of the locomotive and these flags tell all railroad employees that the train is an extra section which will shortly be followed by another section of the same train.
Locomotive 5582 would have been an old locomotive when this picture was taken but the life of a steam locomotive could be very long if it had regular repairs, maintenance and parts replacement.  In England some steam locomotives survived for almost a hundred years in branchline service where the demands for power were not heavy. [The train is spotted beside the water plug, with one of the towers of the Frontenac Floor & Wall Tile factory visible behind it.]
Ballast cleaning is taking place in this photograph.  This train, pictured in the freight yards at Kingston could dig the crushed rock ballast from under the tracks, screen out the dirt, weeds, etc. and replace the ballast as it moved slowly along the tracks.  When it was working on a main line, its track was out of use for regular trains and special, single track working arrangements controlled the other track which had to be used safely by trains running in both directions. [Another view of the FF&WT towers.]
We continue to examine the ballast cleaning process.  Notice the marking on the hopper car, D.L.&W. which showed that the car belonged to the Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad in the United States of America.
SITIO is the first person singular, indicative mood of the Latin verb meaning “I Thirst.”  The circular water tank may have a capacity of ten thousand gallons of water.  That is an indication of the huge amount of water consumed by a large steam locomotive when hauling a heavy train.  The circular tender was known as a Vanderbilt tender. 
CN's 4-8-2 locomotives were not regular visitors to Kingston as there were only a few of them and their normal territory ranged from Toronto west into Southern Ontario.  This train is heading eastwards to Montreal. [CN's steel water tower is just visible over the first coach and supplied the water for the tender-filling plugs, as well as some nearby buildings!]
The small locomotive just in front of the caboose of this freight train was being hauled “dead” perhaps to Montreal.  In 1951 it was probably going to be scrapped. [The freight train is eastbound and several maintenance-of-way cars are on the track just south of the main line, with the Hanley Spur heading to the right just behind them. I have to wonder if this switcher was CN 7359, shown in a photo below, being taken to Montreal's Pointe St Charles shops for repairs and then returned later, facing the opposite way.]
We find a thirsty 6400 class 4-8-4 locomotive in this photograph.  This picture shows that apart from the skyline casing, the deep valance beside the running board and the large diameter of the driving wheels, this loco’s appearance was similar to Canadian National’s other 4-8-4 locomotives. [This is another eastbound train, with the smoke plume of another steam locomotive visible farther east.]
We catch an old timer at work.  Locomotive 7359 is working out its days on switching and wayfreight duties in the Kingston area. [Another locomotive is behind it, with a  Southern Railway boxcar on the Hanley Spur in the background.]
I’ve titled this image, “The Man in Charge!” This engineer has probably brought his train from Belleville to Kingston and will take it to Brockville, a total distance of about 100 miles.  A day’s work for a locomotive crew was measured in miles travelled, not hours worked; a situation which pertained from railroads’ early days.  The number of miles per day’s work did not seem to change as train speeds increased over the years. [Top photo of CN 6215 - while engineers were indeed in charge of their locomotives, a steam-era conductor would likely say that's where his train ended, and the conductor's train began!]
“Double Heading” makes a fine title for this photograph [above].  Your mother, Mary, and I were driving along a country road when I heard the tremendous noise of the exhaust of an approaching train.  Never having previously heard such decibels, I turned down a country lane to be near the tracks.  Two locomotives were working hard to pull a huge freight train up the grade, westbound into Kingston.  This gave me the only picture of a double headed steam hauled train I have ever made.

Saturday 14 October 2023

Modelling the S. Anglin Offices

Fellow Kingston history buff Marc Shaw recently re-posted his ca. 1989 photos of this well-known building at Bay and Wellington Streets. The same photo I'd apparently inadvertently deleted. It was a sign! I saved the photo, printed it, and realized it was time to replace my stand-in Anglin office, lumber yard and shed buildings.
Having driven past the building years earlier during waterfront industrial expeditions, its broad grey expanses of wall, many various windows, sloped roof, location mere feet from the street, and most eye-catchingly, its yellow and red signs made it a great subject for modelling. An earlier B&W photo some years earlier, posted to Bill Anglin's family history page, shows different signage:
A quick appraisal of the space available (never enough!) and materials I could use led me to a Promotex modern warehouse kit I'd purchased from fellow ARK member Michael Pasch at last year's Railfair (this year's is next weekend!). This was the thickest-walled structure kit I'd ever seen, and I'd previously used some walls for my Davis Tannery 2.0. It had a nice smooth stucco-like surface (unlike all those brick structures the manufacturers want to sell us), and would require minimal cutting with a Dremel. I also printed off some Anglin signage that I put together in the Paint program, and some windows I'd formatted from an online search:
Before long, the front, back, one side and roof were Dremeled into submission and glued together:
I applied Dollarama grey craft paint and filled some cracks with Vallejo plastic putty from Leading Edge Hobbies. I added more first-floor and roof overhang with styrene strips from the Promotex kit. Test fit on the layout:
The most fun part - adding the signage. I'm way past cutting window openings into styrene, especially with this kit that was like a fortified bunker on the Maginot Line. So paper cutouts it would be. Stucco means board attached low down to prevent possible vehicle or other damage:
The prototype had some curtained windows, and some showroom windows. A door from the scrap box would do, and I glued an 'S. Anglin' into the skylight. 
I still have to finalize placement. The view here today is a series of row-houses across from the Bajus condominiums.
I painted my former Beaver Lumber lumber storage shed to match. I also have a shed (below) which might receive fire-brick red paint to match the prototype sheds remaining on the site. The awkward thing about the available space on the layout is that the CP spur (also serving Canadian Dredge & Dock and Shell Oil) runs behind the office building. I'll have to shoehorn in an unloading area and reposition the milled lumber on the site. 


Monday 9 October 2023

Locomotives of the Hanley Spur

I've endeavoured to compile a list of locomotives that served CN and CP's waterfront trackage, based on photos I've seen. These are listed by railway, and within each railway by model and year if known. CN 3103 at the Outer Station on June 17, 1977 (Robert Farkas photo). 

CN 7128 switching Wellington Street freight yard with Bajus brewery building in background  - August 1939 Bud Laws collection - Old Time Trains. (Note the angLIN lettering on the Bajus roof):

CN steam:
  • CNR 7128; 7151 in 1948; 7373.
  • CNR 7177 in 1948; 7226 in 1952 and 1953, O-18-c 0-6-0 7510.
CP D-10 807 at Kingston May 1956 - online auction site photo:
CP steam:
  • D4's 417, 423, 424, 434, 437, 445, 453, 485,487.
  • D10 807 in 1956; 1092 in June 1958.
CN diesels stationed at Kingston:
  • RS-3 3018 in 1958-59.
  • S-4 8188 in  June 1967 (black switcher paint scheme).
  • RS-18 3103, 3119 in February 1970; 3108 September 1970; 3117 in June 1974; 3715 in January 1977; 3735 in October 1977; 3634 in April 1982.
  • GP-9.....
  • SW1200RS 1215, 1217 in June 1965; 1238 in 1961; 1316 in 1970.

CP Rail 8025 with Tackaberry and Superior Propane in background - August 25, 1979 (kindly shared by Sam Maclauchlan):
CP diesels from Smiths Falls:
  • 8400's and 8700's after 1959.
  • S-11 6621 in 1963.
  • Tuscan RS-23 8022 in August 1957;  8028-8030 after October 1959; 8029 in May 1965; 8045 in April 1969; 8031 in July 1969.
  • CP Rail-painted S-3 6591 in 1977.
  • CP Rail-painted RS-23 8045 in February 1979; 8030 in April, 1979; 8043 in July 1979. 

I'll keep this post updated with subsequent data points.